Blog ·

Choose Life: How Churches Drift Toward Death—and How to Turn

by Bart Denny

I’ll be the first to admit: I don’t know everything there is to know about church health, vitality, growth, and renewal. And I praise God that He still does what only He can do. I never want to box in the Holy Spirit. After all, we worship a God who parted the sea, turned water into wine, and reversed a crucifixion with a glorious resurrection.

So no, I would never say that God can’t revive a church or that He must act according to my expectations. There are exceptions—even miraculous ones—to the norm. But I will say this: there are patterns. There are trajectories. There are stories that unfold in ways that are, frankly, predictable.

Years of pastoral ministry, doctoral research in church revitalization, and countless conversations with leaders across many church traditions have shown me something sobering. Change the church’s name. Change its denomination. Change its zip code. Change its racial or ethnic makeup. And still, the storyline is often eerily familiar.

The details differ, but the direction is much the same. Left unaltered, the trajectory leads toward decline and, eventually, death.

And sadly, I heard yet another version of that story today: another church comfortably heading toward its own demise.

Rather than identify that particular congregation, let me share some observations drawn from my own experience, my research, and the work of others who have spent years studying dying churches.

The Slow Erosion

As Thom Rainer observes in Autopsy of a Deceased Church, decline often begins with a “slow erosion.” A congregation that once averaged 200 in worship now gathers 70 on a typical Sunday. Yes, sometimes decline follows a dramatic church split. But more often, it unfolds quietly over years.

Families relocate. Faithful saints who walked with Christ for decades are promoted to glory. Yet far more quickly than funerals accumulate, the youth group thins out. The children’s wing grows quieter. Students leave for college and don’t return. Twenty-somethings drift away. The median age rises.

But the warning signs don’t always feel urgent. The younger crowd, after all, wasn’t carrying the budget. Giving remains steady, at least for now. A few new faces appear—usually middle-aged or older believers transferring from a congregation that “went off the rails” by changing the music or shifting direction.

And for many longtime members, life still feels familiar. Their friends are still in the pews. The routines remain intact. The church may be considerably smaller than it was twenty years ago, but Sunday morning still feels like Sunday morning.

Which is precisely why the erosion goes unnoticed—or, perhaps more accurately, unaddressed.

When a Financial Crisis Becomes a Blessing

A church ultimately closes for one of two reasons: it runs out of people, or it runs out of money.

In my own experience as a revitalizing pastor, I feared the latter most. I lay awake some nights wondering if we were simply going to go broke.

Providentially, a few factors slowed the financial bleeding. I worked a second job. My military retirement benefits, including healthcare, eased the burden on the church. The buildings were paid off, which helped—though that didn’t make major repairs, like replacing a failing air conditioner, any less painful.

But here’s the unexpected truth: the fear of insolvency became a strange kind of gift.

It forced clarity. It stripped away denial. It created urgency among longtime members who deeply loved their church and refused to watch it quietly fade away.

When the possibility of closure became real, conversations changed. Prayers intensified. Sacred cows became less sacred. People who had resisted change for years suddenly became willing to consider it.

Sometimes the threat of going broke is the very thing that wakes a church up.

When the Money Outlasts the People

What I’ve come to see more clearly in the years since pastoring a nearly broke church is this: it’s entirely possible for a church to run out of people before it runs out of money.

Some congregations have endowments that quietly cover the bills. The facilities are paid off. In churches that are essentially on life support, the strongest givers are often still faithfully present.

And the church operates exactly the way they prefer. The music fits their taste. The programs reflect their history. The rhythms feel comfortable.

So there’s no financial alarm bell. No crisis meeting. No urgent vote.

Money can anesthetize decline.

When the budget is stable, it’s easy to put on blinders and ignore the more sobering indicators: no young families, no new converts, no baptisms, no emerging leaders, no sense of mission beyond maintaining what remains.

A healthy bank balance can even reinforce the conviction that everything is fine. After all, the bills are paid. The lights are on. The pastor gets his paycheck. What’s the problem?

The problem is that financial stability can conceal a congregation’s approaching death.

And the day of reckoning is still coming—either when the money finally runs thin or when the remaining members simply age out, and there’s no one left to carry the story forward.

When Evangelism Becomes Somebody Else’s Job

Financial stability can also mask another, deeper problem: the quiet outsourcing of evangelism.

In some churches, evangelism has been delegated to the “professionals”—the pastor and the missionaries.

The congregation proudly notes that it gives 40 percent of its budget to foreign missions.

And let me be clear: foreign missions are important. A church with even modest financial stability should support the spread of the gospel to the nations. If a congregation can give generously abroad and still faithfully treat its own neighborhood as a mission field, that is something to celebrate.

But in my own experience, I’ve never seen that balance sustained in a church that has largely abandoned local evangelism.

Too often, generous missions giving becomes a substitute for local gospel engagement. The church sends money overseas while ignoring—or worse, quietly resenting—the changing community just outside its own doors.

The few new people who do come are often examples of transfer growth rather than evangelistic growth. They may even arrive from another declining or dying congregation.

The church has become more interested in keeping the aquarium than fishing for people.

Meanwhile, the surrounding neighborhood becomes something to tolerate rather than reach.

As Mark Clifton argues in Reclaiming Glory, a church that loses sight of its mission to reach its community is on a dangerous trajectory. When a congregation becomes primarily concerned with preserving itself, it has lost sight of why it exists in the first place.

The Leadership Problem Nobody Wants to Discuss

And that brings me to leadership.

As Clifton observes, dying churches frequently fail to hand leadership to the next generation. They cling to it.

My own doctoral research reached a similar conclusion: reaching, developing, and empowering next-generation leaders is a key ingredient in successful church revitalization.

Yet what I’ve seen repeatedly—and what the broader literature on church decline reinforces—is that pastors sometimes stay too long.

Now, let’s be clear. Long pastoral tenure can be a tremendous blessing. A thirty-year pastorate that began when a shepherd was 35 may still be flourishing at 65. Deep trust. Shared history. Fruit that compounds over decades. That’s beautiful.

But I’ve also seen octogenarians still serving as lead pastor. And sometimes, it’s not beautiful.

As I approach my sixties, I feel this personally. I don’t have the same energy I did at 30 or 40. Even at 50, there was a certain mental quickness that required less effort. The changes are subtle, but they’re real.

So I can only imagine what 70 or 80 might feel like in a role that demands vision, adaptability, conflict navigation, emotional resilience, and constant decision-making.

Of course, age alone doesn't determine a pastor's effectiveness. Some older pastors remain remarkably energetic, sharp, and fruitful. And some much younger pastors lack the wisdom or temperament the role requires.

The church should never discard the wisdom that comes with age and experience. We desperately need seasoned saints.

But pastoral ministry is demanding work. When a leader remains in place long after his physical or cognitive vitality has diminished to the point that he can no longer lead effectively, the result is rarely healthy. It is not good for the aging pastor, and it is not good for the church.

At some point, faithful leadership means preparing the next shepherd—not clinging to the staff.

The Myth of the Silver Bullet Pastor

So when the long-tenured pastor finally steps aside—or sadly, passes away, sometimes quite literally in the pulpit—the succession process is often… less than optimal.

The church may endure an extended season of interim leadership. Frequently, the interim pastors are not much younger than the shepherd who just departed. Stability feels comforting. Familiarity feels safe. But it doesn’t necessarily move the church forward.

Eventually, the search committee reaches a conclusion: What we really need is a young pastor with a young family.

He’ll be in his thirties. He’ll have three or four adorable children—none of whom have yet discovered teenage rebellion. His wife will, ideally, play the piano.

He will be energetic, relatable, and visionary.

The Silver Bullet and his photogenic family.

The assumption is simple: young families attract young families.

And sometimes they do—at least initially.

But churches aren’t magnets; they’re communities of relationships. And relationships don’t multiply infinitely.

We’re all like LEGOs. We only have so many relational “nubs.” We can only sustain so many meaningful connections before we run out of bandwidth.

If the only peers for new young families are the pastor and his wife, that’s not enough relational infrastructure to sustain them. They may visit. They may even join. But without broader relationships within the congregation, they often drift away.

Meanwhile, the young pastor—often with sincere conviction and genuine love—begins to address changes that are likely long overdue.

Culture shifts. Worship adjustments. Leadership restructuring. Outreach refocus.

And depending on his wisdom, diplomacy, and timing, things may get tense.

Sometimes they get explosive.

Pastors who follow decades-long pastorates can find themselves carrying an almost impossible weight of expectations. They are supposed to honor the past, attract the young, preserve the traditions, reverse the decline, and somehow accomplish all of this without making anyone uncomfortable.

When resistance, comparison to the former pastor, and accumulated dysfunction become overwhelming, the new pastor may not last long.

I count it a mercy that I lasted more than four years in one such setting, long enough to lead the church into adoption by a larger, healthier congregation that shared my passion for revitalization.

But many pastors don’t last that long.

Instead, a succession of short-term pastorates unfolds. And eventually, the church earns a reputation.

It becomes known as a “pastor eater.”

Make the Course Correction Before You Hit the Rocks

So what do you do?

The first answer takes me back to my years as a naval officer.

If your ship is on a collision course with a shoal, the wisest move is not a last-second, full-rudder panic turn when the rocks are already scraping the hull. The wisest move (and best for the captain’s career) is a small course correction made miles earlier.

A two-degree adjustment out at sea barely feels noticeable on the bridge. But wait too long, and that same correction requires engines back full, alarms sounding, and everyone bracing for impact.

Churches are no different.

Minor drift ignored over the years becomes a major crisis. Small, humble adjustments made early—renewed focus on evangelism, intentional leadership development, honest assessment of health, courageous conversations about change—are far less disruptive than emergency maneuvers when decline is obvious and options are limited.

In other words: pay attention to the charts. Watch the depth sounder. Listen when trusted voices warn of shallow water ahead.

Don’t wait until you hear the grinding of the keel against the rocks.

Already Aground? There Is Still Hope.

“Well, Bart, we’re already aground. Is there anything we can do?”

Yes.

Even in extremis, church death is often still a choice.

But let’s be honest: getting off the rocks requires more than a gentle course correction. It demands a radical change of direction—and the humility to call for help.

At that point, you are not merely revitalizing your church. You are replanting it.

If you belong to a denomination or ministry network, reach out. Invite outside assessment. Ask for coaching.

If you have paid-for facilities that could become a launchpad for a healthy church plant, consider gifting them.

If there is a larger, healthier church in your orbit that could adopt you, praise God. Explore it seriously.

But let’s clear away any illusions.

This will not be a merger of equals.

It cannot be.

Replanting requires submission. The struggling congregation must be willing to come under the leadership, governance, and vision of the denomination, the planting team, or the adopting church.

If you already knew how to reverse the decline on your own, you wouldn’t be in this position.

And, to return to my ship analogy, if you are the captain—at least in the U.S. Navy—and your vessel runs aground, you usually don’t get to be the captain anymore.

That may sound blunt. It is meant to be loving.

Because refusing that humility may amount, functionally, to choosing death.

Why Church Renewal?

These are precisely the kinds of conversations we hope to encourage through Church Renewal, an imprint of True Bearing Press devoted to church revitalization and spiritual revival.

There is no shortage of books promising church growth. Some offer genuinely helpful insights. Others leave pastors and congregations with the impression that if they can just find the right program, adopt the right worship style, or follow the right leadership formula, growth will inevitably follow.

I’m skeptical of formulas.

But I’m convinced that churches can learn from the experiences of others, from careful research, and, above all, from Scripture. We need honest conversations about congregational decline, pastoral leadership, evangelism, discipleship, succession, and the difficult decisions that sometimes accompany renewal.

We also need to recover a biblical understanding of faithfulness. A church's health cannot be reduced to attendance figures, giving reports, or the size of its building. Yet neither should we use faithfulness as an excuse to ignore a congregation's failure to make disciples.

Through Church Renewal, we hope to publish resources that help pastors and congregations face these questions with biblical conviction, practical wisdom, and a willingness to examine some uncomfortable truths.

Because the goal is bigger than keeping church buildings open.

It's about congregations that love God, make disciples, reach their communities, develop new leaders, and bear faithful witness to Jesus Christ.

And sometimes, preserving that witness means being willing to let go of the congregation as we've always known it.

I pray you choose life—for the sake of the gospel, for the sake of your community, and for the sake of the next generation that deserves a living, breathing witness in your town.