Blog ·

When a Good Book Is Too Expensive to Sell

by Bart Denny

Picture a retired missionary who has finally written the book her supporters asked for. It’s three hundred and twenty pages, it’s well written, and it has forty color photographs from thirty years in the field. She uploads the files, chooses premium color so the photos look right, and finds that her paperback has to sell for more than thirty-six dollars before she earns a cent on each copy. The memoirs beside it on the screen sell for half that.

She’s a composite, but her problem is common, and it’s one of the quieter ways a good book fails. Nothing is wrong with the writing. The book costs too much to print for the price readers expect to pay, and the decisions that caused it were made long before anyone saw a price.

Print on demand has made publishing open to almost anyone, which is a good thing. It also means the author now makes the production choices a publisher’s staff used to make, often without seeing what each choice costs.

Where the price comes from

With print on demand, every copy is printed after someone orders it, so every copy carries its own printing cost. The store takes its share of the list price, the printer takes the printing cost, and the author gets what’s left.

On Amazon’s KDP, that works out to a simple formula. For a paperback sold on Amazon.com, the royalty is 60 percent of the list price (50 percent if the list price is under $9.99), minus the printing cost (KDP Paperback Royalty). The printing cost is a fixed charge plus a charge for every page, and the per-page charge depends mostly on the ink (KDP Paperback Printing Cost).

Here’s what that means for one 320-page book at a standard size like 6 by 9 inches, with each of KDP’s three ink choices:

Same words, same pages, and the price needed to earn three dollars a copy runs from about thirteen dollars to over forty. The Expanded Distribution figures deserve a look too. Expanded Distribution, which makes a KDP book available for bookstores and libraries to order, pays 40 percent of the list price minus printing, so a book that barely works on Amazon may not work anywhere else.

Lulu works on a different formula with the same lesson. On Lulu’s own bookstore there’s no distribution fee; through its retail distribution, half the retail price goes to the sales channel. Either way, Lulu subtracts the printing cost, keeps 20 percent of what’s left and pays the author 80 percent, and it requires the list price to be at least twice the printing cost (Lulu Creator Revenue Guide).

Both companies have calculators. Run your numbers before you choose your ink, your trim size and your page count, not after.

What readers will pay

A reader deciding whether to buy your book doesn’t know or care what it cost to print. They compare it with the books around it. If every other memoir on the page is in the high teens and yours is in the forties, most readers won’t stop to find out why.

So the price that counts is set by your category, and you can find it in an afternoon. Search for ten books like yours, from established publishers and from authors publishing on their own, and write down the paperback list prices and page counts. You’ll usually find they cluster. Your book doesn’t have to be the cheapest, but it has to sit inside that cluster, or close enough that the reader can see a reason for the difference.

There are honest exceptions. A gift book full of art, a workbook a church will buy by the case, or a reference book a pastor keeps for twenty years can carry a higher price, because readers expect to pay more for them. A book of prose with some photographs usually isn’t one of those, however good the photographs are.

The cover helps set the expectation too. A reader who sees a gift-book cover will accept a gift-book price, and a reader who sees a paperback memoir won’t. (More on what covers tell readers in The Cover Tells Readers What Kind of Book They’re Holding.)

Decisions that bring the price down

Most of a book’s printing cost is decided by a handful of choices, and nearly all of them can be revisited before publication.

Ink. This is the big one. If a book is mostly words, print it in black and white. Photographs can still go in, in black and white, or as a short color section in a separate edition. Some authors put the color photos on a web page and print a link or a QR code in the book. Save color printing for books where the pictures are the point, such as a coloring book or an illustrated children’s book.

Page count. In black ink, every extra hundred pages on KDP adds $1.20 to the cost of each copy. That’s no reason to cut good material, but it’s a reason to cut repetition, an appendix nobody needs and a second foreword. A good editor usually shortens a manuscript anyway.

Design. Oversized type, wide margins and generous spacing all add pages. A professional interior designer can set a book so it’s comfortable to read without wasting paper. Readability comes first, but there’s often room on both.

Trim size. KDP charges more per page for “large” trims, wider than 6.12 inches or taller than 9 inches. At 320 pages in black ink, the same book costs $6.44 to print at a large size and $4.84 at 6 by 9.

Hardcover. Hardcovers cost more to print and carry higher list prices. They make sense when readers in your category expect them, and they’re a hard sell when they don’t.

One book or two. A 600-page manuscript is sometimes two books. Splitting it can bring each one into a price readers recognize, as long as each half stands on its own.

The ebook. An ebook has no printing cost. It won’t replace a paperback for many Christian readers, but it gives the reader who balks at the print price somewhere else to go.

Price it before you finish it

The missionary’s book can be saved. In black and white, with a short color insert in a special edition or the photographs on a web page, it can sell for the same price as the memoirs beside it and still pay her something on every copy. What she can’t do is fix it after a thousand readers have already scrolled past.

The time to think about price is while the book is still a manuscript, when the ink, the trim and the page count are still open questions. For more on the decisions that come before publication, see Before You Self-Publish. And if you’re writing Christian nonfiction and wondering whether we might be a fit, you can read how publishing with True Bearing Press works.